Comparison to Dermelect - Above It

China Glaze - Bahamian Escape
Middle, Pinky -
Dermelect 'Above It'
Ring -
China Glaze - Secret Peri-winkle

Clearly China Glaze - Secret Periwinkle is the odd man out. (Ring finger)

As a side note, China Glaze - Secret Periwinkle has more in common with Essie - Lapis of Luxury.
Left -
China Glaze - Secret Periwinkle
Right -
Essie - Lapis of Luxury.

More clear from this picture, Above It is not a complete dupe of Bahamian Escape, but they are very close.
As a side note, China Glaze - Bahamian Escape is similar to Color Club - Factory Girl. Factory Girl is brighter.
Left -
China Glaze - Bahamian Escape
Right -
Color Club - Factory Girl
Comparison to Dermelect - Luxurious
Thumb -
Revlon - Gum Drop (Smelly Polish!)
Pointer -
Essie - Lilacism
Middle -
OPI - Rumple's Wiggin'
Ring -
OPI - Do You Lilac It? (more here)
Pinky -
Dermelect- Luxurious
OPI - Do You Lilac It? looks like a dupe for Dermelect - Luxurious
Top -
OPI - Do You Lilac It? (more here)
Bottom -
Dermelect- Luxurious
Comparison to Dermelect - Persuasive
Pointer, Ring -
Color Club - Vintage Couture
Middle, Pinky -
Dermelect - Persuasive
I think here you can tell Dermelect is only slightly more peach and muted, but not by much.
Overall, these two are difficult to distinguish in certain lighting situations. Like I mentioned in the last post, Persuasive is a bit of a chameleon.
Top -
Dermelect - Persuasive
Bottom -
Color Club - Vintage Couture
It's nice to have choices! :D
*The Dermelect polishes were sent for review*